When a ward dies, most families assume the guardianship is over. In one sense it is. There is no longer a living person for the guardian to care for or make decisions for. But there is still work to do. Someone has to make funeral arrangements. Someone has to turn the ward’s property over to the right person. And in a family that has already been fighting in court for years, the death often starts a new round of lawsuits.
That raises a practical question. If the guardianship case is still sitting open on the probate court’s docket after the ward dies, can the probate court still use it? Specifically, can it pull a brand-new lawsuit, like a wrongful death claim, out of district court and into the guardianship case?
The Texas Supreme Court answered that question in In re Guardianship of Fairley, No. 20-0328, 650 S.W.3d 372 (Tex. Mar. 4, 2022). The court had to decide whether a ward’s death ends the guardianship proceeding itself, or only the guardianship of the person, and whether the probate court still had jurisdiction to transfer the ward’s daughter’s wrongful death suit into its own court after he died.
Facts and Procedural History
The fight was between James Fairley’s wife, Mauricette, and his daughter, Juliette. The court described it as having “a tortured procedural history,” and it spanned a decade. It started in Bexar County in 2011, when James was 81 and Juliette claimed he needed a guardian. A guardian ad litem decided a guardianship wasn’t necessary, and that case was closed. In 2012 Juliette applied to be appointed James’s permanent guardian, but she agreed to nonsuit that application in exchange for promises about James’s care and her access to him. The probate court dismissed it in September 2014.
One month later, Juliette took James from his San Antonio assisted-living facility to New York, where she lived. Mauricette asked the Bexar County probate court to appoint her as James’s temporary guardian. She alleged that Juliette had unlawfully removed James and had defrauded him into signing powers of attorney that Juliette used to take money from his bank account. Juliette then filed her own guardianship petition in New York. After a December 1, 2014 hearing, the New York court appointed Mauricette and a court evaluator as “special temporary co-guardians” for the limited purpose of bringing James back to Texas, and it revoked the powers of attorney in Juliette’s favor.
Back in Texas, Mauricette filed an application on December 8, 2014 to be appointed James’s permanent guardian, in the same court and under the same cause number as her temporary guardianship application. The probate court made her temporary guardian, and after a November 2015 hearing, appointed her permanent guardian of James’s person, finding him “totally incapacitated.” The applications sought guardianship of James’s person only, not his estate.
Juliette appealed the appointment, arguing the probate court should not have required her to deposit $20,000 as security for costs and then dismissed her competing application when she didn’t pay. She lost. She then filed mandamus petitions in the San Antonio Court of Appeals and the Texas Supreme Court, eventually arguing that every order entered after September 2014 was void because James had been served by a private process server rather than by a sheriff or other officer. James died in December 2018, while that mandamus petition was pending. The Supreme Court denied it in January 2019.
Juliette then sued Mauricette and Mauricette’s other daughter, Dorothy (James’s stepdaughter), in Bexar County district court for wrongful death and to stop the embalming or cremation of James’s body. On Mauricette and Dorothy’s motion, the probate court transferred that suit into the guardianship case. Mauricette and Dorothy moved to dismiss it under Rule 91a. Juliette responded with a motion to dismiss under the Texas Citizens Participation Act, asking the probate court to vacate the transfer order. The probate court denied her motion, and the San Antonio Court of Appeals affirmed. In re Guardianship of Fairley, 604 S.W.3d 450 (Tex. App.—San Antonio 2020).
In the Supreme Court, Juliette made two jurisdictional arguments. The one that matters here is simple: James was dead, so the guardianship was over, so there was nothing left in the probate court to transfer her wrongful death suit into. If she was right, her suit would go back to district court.
When Does a Guardianship Proceeding Begin and End?
To understand Juliette’s argument, we first have to look at what a statutory probate court can transfer into a guardianship case, and how long a guardianship case lasts.
Texas Estates Code § 1022.007(a) allows a statutory probate court judge, on the motion of a party or a person interested in the guardianship, to transfer to his or her court “from a district, county, or statutory court a cause of action that is a matter related to a guardianship proceeding pending in the statutory probate court,” and then consolidate it with the guardianship proceeding. The key word is “pending.” If there is no guardianship proceeding pending, there is nothing to transfer a case into.
The Estates Code defines a “guardianship proceeding” broadly. It means “a matter or proceeding related to a guardianship or any other matter covered by this title,” including the appointment of a guardian. Tex. Est. Code § 1002.015. And it tells us exactly when that proceeding starts and stops. Under § 1022.002(d), the proceeding runs “[f]rom the filing of the application for the appointment of a guardian of the estate or person, or both, until the guardianship is settled and closed under this chapter.” During that time it “is one proceeding for purposes of jurisdiction.”
In plain terms, the case doesn’t end when the ward stops needing care. It ends when the court formally settles and closes the guardianship and discharges the guardian. Until that happens, the case is still open, and the probate court still has jurisdiction over it.
The Estates Code also expects the guardian to keep working after the ward dies. Section 1204.051 provides that “[b]efore a guardianship of the person or estate of a ward is closed on the ward’s death,” the guardian may, subject to the court’s approval, make funeral arrangements and pay funeral expenses and other debts out of the deceased ward’s estate. And under § 1204.108(a), when a guardianship must be settled, the guardian of the person has to deliver the ward’s property in the guardian’s possession or control to the personal representative of the deceased ward’s estate or other person entitled to it. Those duties only make sense if the guardianship case is still alive after the death.
How the Court Decided the Probate Court Still Had Jurisdiction
The court first dealt with mootness. Mauricette argued James’s death made the whole appeal moot. The court disagreed. A case is moot only when a live controversy no longer exists. If Juliette was right about jurisdiction, her wrongful death suit would be reinstated in district court. So there was still a live dispute, regardless of James’s death: “whether the district court is the proper court to adjudicate her wrongful-death suit.”
Then the court turned to Juliette’s main argument, that James’s death ended the guardianship and left no “guardianship proceeding pending” for the transfer. The court rejected it.
It started with the statute. Because § 1022.002(d) says the proceeding begins when the application is filed, the probate court acquired subject-matter jurisdiction when Mauricette filed her first application, the one seeking a temporary guardianship. And because the same section says the proceeding lasts until the guardianship is settled and closed, the question was whether that had happened yet.
The court then drew the line that decides the case. “A ward’s death will necessarily bring the guardianship of the person to an end,” the court said, citing Zipp v. Wuemling, 218 S.W.3d 71, 74 (Tex. 2007) (“It is axiomatic that, with the death of the ward, the guardianship of the person must end.”). “But the guardianship proceeding does not automatically terminate on the ward’s death.” Instead, the probate court’s jurisdiction continues until the court settles and closes the guardianship and discharges the guardian.
That rule is not new. The court relied on Easterline v. Bean, 49 S.W.2d 427, 428 (Tex. 1932), which held that a ward’s death causes the probate court to lose jurisdiction over the guardianship “save and except that the guardianship shall be immediately settled and closed, and the guardian discharged.” So even under that older rule, the court kept its authority to settle and close the guardianship after the ward’s death. The court pointed to §§ 1204.051 and 1204.108(a) as confirmation that the Estates Code expects the guardian to act on a deceased ward’s behalf before the guardianship is closed.
Applying that here was easy. It was undisputed that the probate court had not settled and closed the guardianship when it transferred Juliette’s wrongful death suit. So there was still a guardianship proceeding pending, and James’s death “did not deprive the probate court of subject-matter jurisdiction to enter the transfer order.” Juliette didn’t challenge the transfer on any other ground.
The court did add a caution in a footnote. Just because a probate court can transfer a case into a guardianship after the ward dies doesn’t always mean it should. A probate court deciding whether to transfer a related case under § 1022.007 “should take into account the death of the ward and the forthcoming closure of the guardianship proceeding, as well as whether there is a pending or imminent probate proceeding into which the cause of action should be transferred instead.”
Juliette’s second argument, that improper service on James voided every order in the case, also failed. The court held that technical defects in who served James did not void the orders, because James was personally served and appeared through his court-appointed attorney ad litem without objecting. The court affirmed the court of appeals’ judgment. Justice Devine, joined by Justice Blacklock, dissented.
The Takeaway
Fairley separates two things that are easy to confuse: the guardianship and the guardianship proceeding. A ward’s death ends the guardianship of the person. It does not end the case. The case stays open, and the probate court keeps jurisdiction, until the court settles and closes the guardianship and discharges the guardian.
That has real consequences. If you are a guardian, your job isn’t done when the ward dies. You may still need court approval for funeral expenses, you have to turn the ward’s property over to the right person, and you need to get the guardianship formally closed. If you are a family member thinking about suing over a ward’s care or death, you should expect that, in a county with a statutory probate court like El Paso, the probate court may pull your case into the guardianship file as long as it remains open, even if you filed in district court. And if you want to fight a transfer, arguing that the death ended the case won’t work. The better argument, based on the court’s footnote, is that the guardianship is about to close and the claim belongs in the estate’s probate case instead, if there is one.
Our El Paso Probate Attorneys provide a full range of probate services to our clients, including helping with guardianship proceedings, closing a guardianship after a ward’s death, and the estate and wrongful death disputes that often follow. Affordable rates, fixed fees, and payment plans are available. We provide step-by-step instructions, guidance, checklists, and more for completing the probate process. We have years of combined experience that we can use to support and guide you with probate and estate matters. Call us today for a FREE consultation.
Disclaimer
The content of this website is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. The information presented may not apply to your situation and should not be acted upon without consulting a qualified probate attorney. We encourage you to seek the advice of a competent attorney with any legal questions you may have.





